Step 1. Schedule A Tasting
The first step is a delicious one… Schedule your Cake Consultation and tasting today! Collaborate one-on-one with an experienced member of the Buttercooky team to bring your dreams into a delicious reality. Our team will meet with you to create and design a cake that incorporates your ideas and vision.
Customers are welcome to stop by or call one of our locations to inquire about a cake without an appointment. If upon arrival it is determined that your cake requires more customization, an appointment will be scheduled with one of our cake consultants.
Buttercooky Bakery would love nothing more than to top-off your big event with a personalized, customized cake almost too beautiful to eat!
Step 2. Meet Your Design Consultant
Create your own custom party cake online!
Create a cake all your own! Add your choice of fillings, frostings, fruit and decorations to customize the perfect cake for your event! We have several photos of our cakes in order to give you an idea of the design options available, but the combinations are almost endless!
Pick your favorite cake flavor and filling to make this design the perfect cake for your event! Gluten free and vegan options are also available! Don’t have time to build your own cake? Then head over to our Pre-Made Cakes page and order one of our standard cake designs, where the flavor combos are pre-determined.
Step 3. Delivery On Time, Every Time.
We deliver to just about any venue within the Long Island and NY Metropolitan area.
As part of our service, we will work directly with you or your event planner to schedule a delivery and to check that all arrangements for assembly such as the cake stand and cake table have been taken care of. Our delivery team is on time every time so you don’t have to worry.
Should you wish to pick up your cake, we will provide you with full transport, assembly and storage instructions where required.